Chile will submit new evidence to FIFA to strengthen case to have Ecuador kicked out of World Cup


FIFA have summoned Byron Castillo to attend Thursday’s hearing of their Appeals Commission following Sportsmail’s bombshell revelations that the Ecuador international confessed to being born in Colombia in an official investigation four years ago.

The president of the Chilean FA, Pablo Milad, welcomed Sportsmail’s publication of Castillo’s interview with investigators in which he admitted to using a false birth certificate, but the player’s lawyer claimed the new evidence was not admissible as the row between the two countries escalated.

FIFA also responded to the story by sending an updated request to the Ecuador Football Federation [FEF] for Castillo to attend the hearing in Zurich, writing that ‘the Ecuadorian Football Association is requested to ensure that the player Byron David Castillo Segura is made available and attends’.

Their previous communication with FEF had said Ecuador are ‘requested to ensure, in the best extent possible’ that Castillo attend, which FIFA sources confirmed represented a significant change of emphasis.

Castillo has never publicly discussed his birth or background, although the evidence he gave to an Investigative Commission set up by FEF in 2018 appears clear-cut.

In an audio recording published by Sportsmail on Monday, Castillo gives a name and birth date matching his Colombian certificate, and details moving from Tumaco to San Lorenzo in Ecuador to pursue a professional career, also naming a businessman he claimed provided him with a new birth certificate.

Byron Castillo (left) played against Chile in World Cup qualifying and they could be given two 3-0 victories if he is found to have been ineligible 

The name of Byron Castillo was given on the Ecuadorian birth certificate

His real name is Bayron Javier Castillo Segura and his Colombian birth certificate shows it

The name of Byron Castillo was given on the Ecuadorian birth certificate (left), while his real name of Bayron Javier Castillo Segura is on the Colombian birth certificate (right)

FIFA have summoned Castillo to attend Thursday's hearing of their Appeals Commission

FIFA have summoned Castillo to attend Thursday’s hearing of their Appeals Commission 

Castillo’s apparent confession could result in Ecuador being kicked out of the World Cup just two months before they are due to face Qatar in the tournament’s opening fixture. 

Chile would replace Ecuador if FIFA followed recent precedent by awarding them two 3-0 victories for the matches in which Castillo played against them, although in other possible scenarios Peru or Italy could also be handed a back-door entry to the World Cup. 

CFA president Milad claimed on Tuesday that the new evidence vindicated Chile’s claim.

‘This recording substantiates that our claim and complaint is correct,’ he said.

‘From the player’s mouth, he recognizes his nationality and everything he did. This strengthens our position. It is an external proof that we did not have within the evidence that we presented, but it consolidates the case and shows truth in our complaint.

‘Now, we will wait for what the appeals chamber decides with this subpoena that we have on September 15. I hope the player goes. I believe that he cannot deny what he himself said and the accusations that he has made against the Ecuadorian federation.

‘We did not have the direct background of this audio, we are surprised and happy that this recording has come out. We did have a history that this player was Colombian and that he deceived the whole world.’

A lawyer for the Chilean FA, Eduardo Carlezzo, confirmed that the interview with Castillo was not part of the evidence they presented to FIFA when their case was dismissed at the initial hearing in June, but that it would be submitted this week.

‘We knew this audio existed, because it was clearly mentioned in official papers, but we were unaware of its content,’ Carlezzo said.

‘The recording validates everything we have said since the beginning of this case. Clearly this now needs to be submitted as evidence to FIFA’s Appeal Committee before Thursday’s hearing.’

Pablo Milad, president of the Chilean FA, welcomed Sportsmail's newly obtained evidence

Pablo Milad, president of the Chilean FA, welcomed Sportsmail’s newly obtained evidence

This is documentation to go with audio of Byron Castillo during the Ecuadorian investigation

This is documentation to go with audio of Byron Castillo during the Ecuadorian investigation

Castillo’s lawyer Andres Holguin claimed that as the evidence was not submitted in the original hearing it was irrelevant.

‘The audio that is circulating is nothing new,’ Holguin said. ‘In addition, a constitutional judge did not consider it as evidence since it could not be certified that it was from Castillo.

‘The crucial interview with Castillo in which he appears to admit that his official documents are fake took place in Ecuador in December 2018. In the interview Castillo is asked by the investigator, “when exactly were you born?” to which he replies, “In 95.” The investigator’s next questions is, “And which year does the ID have?” an inquiry which gets the response “98.”

Castillo is then asked, “What are your real names?” to which he answers, “Bayron Javier Castillo Segura.”

He continued: ‘I crossed the border because, you know, teams from Tumaco play in San Lorenzo. I went to do some trials in San Lorenzo, I remember that very well. I never got picked for any of the teams at those trials, but my friend who was picked never turned up so I went instead.

Castillo was a fixture in the Ecuador team for their World Cup qualifying campaign

Castillo was a fixture in the Ecuador team for their World Cup qualifying campaign  

Above is a copy of the document showing the player's Colombian baptism certificate

Above is a copy of the document showing the player’s Colombian baptism certificate

‘I went home, I told my parents that I have to go, but in that time we didn’t have any money, I remember that very well. There was no money. And I started crying. So my Dad said maybe another time and my Mum as well. My mum was worried, she didn’t want to do this to me and this and that. And I was worried. My Dad left around 7, he came back at 11 or 12, with money, 20,000 Colombian pesos. With that I travelled to San Lorenzo.

‘I arrived and I didn’t know how to fix things. I didn’t know. They said this and that. We are going to do this, we are going to help you. I needed help. I came here because I wanted to help my family. I knew the situation there in Tumaco. I arrived and started playing without any problem, oblivious. And just now I see all the problems come up.’

The Chile FA have obtained a baptism certificate from Tumaco in the name Bayron Javier Castillo Segura, but one does not exist in the name of Byron David Castillo Segura. 

The birth certificate of Colombia has been validated by the birth registry and ministry for foreign relations, but the birth certificate of Ecuador was not recognised by the country’s civil register.

In addition, the signature of his father Harrinson Jose Castillo in the Ecuadorian document does not correspond to the signature in the Colombian document.

Castillo played eight times as Ecuador qualified for the 2022 World Cup in Qatar

Castillo played eight times as Ecuador qualified for the 2022 World Cup in Qatar